Soy Lecithin and 3 Dumb Paleo Questions
Is Soy Lecithin Paleo?
This question – or the same question with a different food or ingredient inserted – is probably the most popular question asked in all of Paleo-land.
Lately, several bloggers have argued that we shouldn’t ask if a food is Paleo. They say we should just ask if it’s healthy.
I don’t agree.
Just asking if a food is healthy hasn’t really worked. Paleo works partially because it offers a simple explanation and framework for how to eat and live better.
And yet, asking if Soy Lecithin is Paleo is a DUMB question. (Sorry kids, despite what you were told in school, there are both dumb questions and dumb answers.)
I’m going to explain why it’s a dumb question (probably not what you think), but first…
What is Soy Lecithin?
In the simplest terms, soy lecithin a byproduct of soybean oil production.
It’s extracted either mechanically or using a chemical called hexane. It contains pretty much none of the soy proteins that we try to avoid, although it does contain many of the phyto-estrogens inherent to soy.
It’s used in a very wide variety of foods, including confectionery, doughs, and cooking sprays, and candy bars.
The main benefit of soy lecithin is that it acts as an emulsifier, which means that it stabilized foods like candy bars and makes them stick together instead of breaking apart.
There are many websites out there that will give you a lot more detail about what soy lecithin is (for example, see this article or this article).
This brings me to Dumb Question #1
1. Is Soy Lecithin Paleo?
Of all the foods that Paleo people ask about, Soy Lecithin is one of the most popular.
Do you know why?
You would expect people to ask about foods that have been eaten for a very long time (like potatoes or dairy). And to be sure, those are also popular foods to ask about.
But soy lecithin???
People ask about soy lecithin, because they see it listed as an ingredient in their chocolate bars.
Most chocolate contains soy lecithin. It’s what holds the chocolate together (an oversimplification).
This is a dumb question for 2 reasons:
First, the answer is obvious: Of course Soy Lecithin isn’t Paleo.
If you Google it and read 3 sentences about what it is, then it’s obvious that it didn’t exist a thousand years ago, much less a million.
And when you ask if something is Paleo, that’s pretty much the only standard you can use for an answer – did it exist a very long time ago?
Rule: If you have to ask if a food is Paleo, it’s not. And if you don’t want to feel guilty, don’t ask. – Click to Tweet
But there’s a second reason why this is a dumb question, and that’s because it’s not an honest question. It’s masking another question:
2. Is Soy Lecithin Healthy?
What people really want to know when they ask if Soy Lecithin is Paleo is whether it’s healthy.
But like the first question, this question is dumb for the same 2 reasons:
First, the answer is pretty obvious: Of Course Not.
If you search enough, you’ll find articles about Soy Lecithin contains Choline, which is good for you. (Big deal). Just because it contains one vitamin or mineral does not make it healthy.
Soy Lecithin has practically no nutritional value, it’s almost always GMO, and although it doesn’t have many of the harmful proteins contained in other soy products, it does contain harmful phytoestrogens. In addition, if you’re allergic to soy, it’s also possible that you’re allergic to soy lecithin.
Soy Lecithin is not healthy, and most people know this pretty intuitively. I mean when was the last time you told yourself “I really need to get some more soy lecithin in my diet”?
Again, though, asking if Soy Lecithin is healthy is really just a sneaky way of asking the 3rd dumb question:
Can I Eat My Dark Chocolate Anyway?
This is the dumbest question of all.
So here’s my dumb answer: You can eat whatever you want.
And here’s my slightly less dumb answer: Chocolate (even dark) isn’t good for you, and it’s not Paleo.
You heard me: Dark Chocolate is Not Paleo or Healthy.
Dark Chocolate is Neither Paleo nor Healthy. – Click to Tweet
Cacao beans might have existed forever, but it wasn’t even until a couple thousand years ago that people learned to grind and mix the beans.
Sure, there are certain positive health aspects of dark chocolate, but even 85% dark chocolate is still 15% sugar. I don’t think all sugar is evil, but let’s not kid ourselves into thinking that it’s a healthy or nutritious food.
And as for the soy lecithin, how much difference is that going to make anyway? It’s always less than 1% of dark chocolate, and really, unless you’re eating many chocolate bars per day, the soy lecithin is going to have far less of an impact on your health than the sugar is (unless, of course, you’re allergic to soy).
Now, none of this means that you should never eat dark chocolate. Most of us find it pretty impossible to never eat food that isn’t nutritious or healthy. And personally, I don’t want to never eat dark chocolate.
But don’t deceive yourself about it somehow being Paleo or being healthy. It’s not as bad as pizza, donuts, or Mountain Dew, but still…
So This Was a Bit of A Rant…
But here’s a secret: I don’t actually think the questions are dumb. I think the questions are dishonest.
Most people who ask these questions are looking for ways to deceive themselves. And that’s not productive or healthy.
I’ve asked questions like these many times in my life, and I now realize (most of the time) that I’m not being very honest with myself when I ask these questions.
When you ask questions like “Is Soy Lecithin Paleo,” you’re generally not looking for information that will help you live a better or healthier life. You’re generally looking for information that will confirm what you want to hear (e.g. – that it’s OK to eat dark chocolate).
And when you look for that kind of information, that’s what you’re going to find, regardless of whether it’s healthy or not.
Being healthy or successful is not about what you know, it’s about asking honest questions and seeking honest answers.
What do you think?
Photos courtesy of anitasarkeesian, pasukaru76, mikebaird, and Live?Laugh?Love.
I think that was well said. Enough so that I clipped the last part to remind myself of, later. Most of us NEED to be more honest with ourselves, first, so that we can be honest with others. It is so easy to want to think something that isn’t true.